Paying twice for the same person | Nevent Skip to main content
nevent.
Login Request information
Fans in a festival crowd, the same audience that comes back edition after edition
Analysis

Paying twice for the same person

A Forbes report on festivals leaves one question unanswered: what it costs to reach someone with ads again after they've already bought a ticket.

There’s a line in Forbes’ New Markets special on the festival industry that sums up the last decade’s shift better than any consulting report. It comes from Hugo Albornoz, of Superstruct: “We used to sell tickets and book a lineup; today we manage communities.”

Given who’s saying it, this isn’t a marketing line. Superstruct runs 40 festivals and 110 events a year. When someone at that scale says their business is no longer the box office but the community, the rest of the report is worth reading closely.

I’ve read all of it, and there’s one part I disagree with. But before I get there, I have to admit that the part I do agree with is better explained than it usually is.

The machine the report describes works

The underlying diagnosis is solid and the numbers back it up: 807.2 million euros in live music revenue in Spain in 2025, up 110% on 2019 and five times the 2013 figure. The sector hasn’t just grown, it has changed shape. Albornoz describes it as the move from a three-day event to “a platform that operates all year round”, something that “forces you to think of the festival as a continuous product, not a seasonal one”.

The most interesting part of the special is built on that idea: the data. Alberto Amaro, of 014 Media, explains how DataFest Media works, the initiative they’ve launched with Superstruct using data from more than 35 festivals in Spain: “basically, we turn the experience of being there live, enjoying the music, into very precise digital profiles”. And he adds the distinction that, in my view, is the most valuable line in the whole document: “targeting someone who seems interested in music based on their digital behavior is not the same as targeting a person who has actually bought a ticket”.

That’s the whole thing. The difference between inferred interest and real behavior is the difference between guessing and knowing. Amaro wraps it up: “the real value lies in matching the physical and digital worlds”.

Then the report explains what’s done with that data, which is where my disagreement begins: digital campaigns on Meta, TikTok, Google, Spotify and programmatic environments, using audiences built from real attendees.

In other words, the loop takes the data of the people who paid to be there and hands it back to the platforms to buy reach again.

Before going on, the answer a promoter would give me

Whenever I’ve raised this in industry conversations, the reply is always the same, and it’s a good one. I’m reproducing it as it was given to me, because it deserves to be in the text, not in a footnote.

They rent it because the numbers work.

A promoter with three events a year and six people in the office puts 8,000 euros into Meta on a Tuesday and by Friday knows whether it sold. They don’t have two seasons to build a relationship: they have a venue to fill in eight weeks and cash flow that depends on ticket revenue coming in. The CPM isn’t what’s expensive. Waiting is.

There’s also a common misunderstanding about why you upload your own database to an ad platform. You don’t upload it to hit the people who are already yours. You upload it so the platform can find people who look like them. The 20,000 buyers you already have aren’t your growth problem, they’re the seed. The problem is the 200,000 who don’t know you yet, and you won’t reach them by emailing your list. Money that looks wasted from the outside is, in many cases, the only thing that grows attendance.

And a third objection, the one I find hardest to counter: talking directly to your audience isn’t free. It takes someone writing every week, building segments, handling unsubscribes and consents and keeping an eye on deliverability. That person costs more per year than the campaign. They don’t show up on any Meta invoice, but they’re on the payroll.

Add to that something the report itself reveals. Among the sources through which an attendee discovers an event are the artists’ channels and ads, and the newsletters and direct communications from ticketing companies. The audience’s loyalty belongs to the artist, and the direct channel that already works usually belongs to someone else. Asking a mid-sized promoter to act like a media brand twelve months a year is asking them to compete for attention they have no natural claim to. Brunch Electronik can. Sónar can. The two-day festival in a provincial city, with six people in the office, is nobody in November.

All of this is true. And still, I think the conclusion drawn from it is wrong.

The question isn’t the first attendee, it’s the fifth

Nobody disputes the first purchase. To reach people who don’t know you, paid advertising is the tool and there’s no realistic alternative: the report notes that 46% of brands increased their live investment compared to 2024, and money goes where it works.

The debate is a different one. The problem isn’t how much it costs to acquire someone the first time. It’s how much it costs to acquire the same person the fifth time. If every edition you pay full price to reach an audience that has already bought two, three or four times, what you’re buying isn’t growth: it’s introducing yourself again to someone who already knew you.

And this isn’t just my hunch, the report comes back to it quite insistently. Marc Muñoz, of Brunch Electronik, says that “what matters isn’t just how many people come, but how many want to come back”, and gives his figure: 48% new buyers, which read the other way round means more than half his audience returns. Albornoz talks about having “a loyal, recurring community” as the moment when “you stop being just a show organizer”. And when Superstruct describes its audience, it doesn’t give a number, it gives a ladder: 3.5 million direct customers, 9 million total audience and up to 12 million interested people.

That ladder is the key, and the order they list it in isn’t accidental either. The three rungs aren’t worth the same, nor do they cost the same to reach. Treating them all alike, buying blanket reach for all three, is the most expensive way to fill a venue.

The stated goal of DataFest Media, according to the report, is for “brands to keep talking to that audience intelligently long after” the festival. I think that’s an excellent definition. I’ll just point out who the subject of that sentence is. Brands.

What the report doesn’t answer

The special describes the top of the pyramid. Superstruct has its own owned-media platform, a partner like 014 Media, and anonymization, hashing and data cleanroom processes. It’s a serious setup, with a team and a budget, and it holds up because its cost is spread across 40 festivals. Spread across three, it doesn’t.

The promoter running three events a year doesn’t appear in the report, and by numbers they’re almost the whole sector. The open question, which I haven’t seen answered here or anywhere else, is what the small version of this looks like.

It isn’t building a media platform. Nor is it cutting ad spend, which would be bad advice. I think it starts with something more modest and far less glamorous: knowing what share of your attendance is already recurring and no longer paying the discovery price for that share. It’s a measurement question before it’s a channel question. If you don’t know how many of this year’s attendees came last year, you can’t know how much you’re overpaying, and no ad platform will give you that figure, because it isn’t their job to.

There’s one last figure from the Estudio Pulso worth keeping in mind before deciding your audience wants nothing to do with you outside the venue: 57% of attendees view the presence of brands at events positively. They don’t tolerate it, they value it. 94% say music is an important part of their lives and helps them regulate their emotions, and 88% say it’s part of their identity. These people aren’t waiting to be left alone. They’re waiting for what reaches them to have something to do with them.

The promoter who tells me the numbers work is right. They work on the first sale. What almost nobody is calculating, in this report or in most of the sector’s offices, is what the second one costs.


Opinion piece on the New Markets special by Forbes España (September 2026). The full report is here. I write from a company that works in this space, so factor in the bias: the lines that made me write this article aren’t mine, they come from the people on the other side of the table.

See our platform in action

Learn how Nevent can take your events to the next level

Get strategies to fill your events